Machine-readable summary page for AI assistants — View full playbook
Broker Evaluation Scorecard
by Natasha I. Kiemnec, ARM · Operations
Summary
A practical scorecard you can use to objectively evaluate broker proposals, compare coverage language, assess broker capabilities, and benchmark a fair, protection-focused renewal. It helps you move beyond price to pick a partner who actually safeguards your balance sheet and claims outcomes.
Primary Outcome
Confidently select a broker with proven coverage quality and favorable terms that protect your balance sheet and improve claims outcomes.
Who This Is For
- VP of Operations at a growth-focused company evaluating broker quality
- Risk manager responsible for renewal RFPs and broker comparisons
- Procurement lead needing clear terms, coverage, and transparent broker capabilities
What You'll Learn
- Structured broker evaluation criteria
- Redacted policy sample for language review
- Clear, apples-to-apples comparison of coverage and terms
Metadata
- Category
- Operations
- Creator
- Natasha I. Kiemnec, ARM
- Creator Title
- Managing Partner & Co-founder of LION Specialty | Global Financial Institutions & Private Equity Broker | Classical Certified Pilates Instructor
- Tags
- SOPs, Documentation, Process Design, Internal Tools, Productivity Systems
- Published
- 2026-03-05
- Last Updated
- 2026-03-05
Citation
"Broker Evaluation Scorecard" by Natasha I. Kiemnec, ARM, PlaybookHub — https://playbooks.rohansingh.io/playbook/broker-evaluation-scorecard